Restaurant Review of Brewsters Seafood Market

Heard about this place and decided to try it for the first time with my wife and 2 year old baby. We observed people coming and going and seemed to be OK with sitting down and seeing how the food was. Our Appetizer was Fried Calamari which was so so,it was tough and rubbery and the marinara tasted like it came from a jar.I wouldn't order it again or suggest it. We each ordered a sandwich and two of them were signature dishes. I decided to go for the oyster po boy, my wife the hot lobster sandwich, my daughter the fried flounder sandwich. 1st one of the worst things you can do to a sandwich is burn the bread, well they did that on all three sandwiches which instantly ruins them. The po boy was fried oysters on burnt bread, lettuce and tomato, no sauce, nothing, that's not a po boy. My wife had lobster that was over cooked and it was only a few claws. We informed our waitress of this and showed her all the rolls with burnt bread sitting on the side, she said Im sorry here is your $66 lunch bill..........wont return! Eater Beware 252 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY